Eh. I think I have to disagree that the potion itself was the Horcrux. The Snape/Dumbledore interaction could just as easily be explained by Dumbledore being damaged from the destruction of the ring, by his realization that Snape was more important to what they were doing than he was, and by the 'him or me' with Snape under the Umbreakable Vow. I think it's also unlikely because of the demonstration of Voldemort's prediliction for trophies: what's so special about some weird potion? I haven't read the entire essay, but unless she addressed that, I think the supposition is weak.
Her Ravenclaw theory actually addresses that and explains how Regulus could've managed to switch the lockets as well.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
timeasmymeasure
no subject
Date: 2005-07-20 04:45 pm (UTC)Her Ravenclaw theory actually addresses that and explains how Regulus could've managed to switch the lockets as well.